Isolating good quality DNA is an essential requirement for carrying out any genetic studies on plants and animals. It is also important to maintain the quality and yield of the DNA and avoid any cross contaminations during DNA extraction. Read this article to find out the important differences between plant and animal DNA extraction.

What is Plant DNA Extraction?

In plant DNA extraction, fresh leaves (15-20 days age) are taken and the cell wall is ruptured by mechanical grinding either in mortar-pestle or liquid nitrogen. The main objective of DNA isolation is to yield excellent quality of DNA molecules in a quick, inexpensive and consistent method. The principle behind the plant extraction method is to break the cell wall, cell membrane and nuclear membrane to release intact DNA molecules and later remove other cellular components such as proteins, phenols, lipids and secondary metabolites. The most common methods of plant DNA extraction are CTAB method and sodium dodecyl sulphate based method (Edward’s method).

Let us look at the CTAB buffer in brief.

  • The CTAB buffer is composed of CTAB (Cetyltrimethylammonium bromide), NaCl, EDTA (ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid), Tris, PVP (polyvinylpyrrolidone) and β-mercaptoethanol. It is mixed with plant leaves and grinded mechanically.
  • CTAB is a cationic detergent that weakens the cell wall along with the mechanical pressure exerted on the plant leaves.
  • NaCl helps to remove proteins that are bound to the DNA.
  • Tris is (hydroxymethyl) aminomethane is a buffer with pH ranging from 7 to 9 that increases the permeability of the cell wall.
  • EDTA is a divalent cation that reduces the activity of cellular DNase and RNase.
  • Î’-mercaptoethanol clears the tannins and polyphenols so as to obtain pure DNA extract.
  • PVP also removes all the phenolic compounds from the DNA extract.

What is Animal DNA Extraction?

Animal DNA extraction is commonly done using animal blood but sometimes muscle tissues or skin swabs are also used. Since animals do not have a cell wall, mechanical grinding is not required in the extraction. The most common method of extraction is the phenol-chloroform method. It is a liquid-liquid extraction technique that uses the principle of immiscibility to separate the upper aqueous phase and a lower organic phase.

The sample is lysed and mixed with equal amounts of phenol and chloroform and centrifuged. Two immiscible layers are obtained: an upper aqueous layer consisting of phenol, chloroform, nucleic acids, salts and sugars; and a lower organic phase that consists of the hydrophobic lipids along with proteins at the interphase of the two layers.

Plant vs Animal DNA Extraction

Plant DNA Extraction

Animal DNA Extraction

Extraction

It is the extraction of plant DNA from plant parts.

It is the extraction of DNA from animal blood, muscle tissues or skin swabs.

Level of Difficulty

Plant DNA is difficult to extract.

Animal DNA is easier to extract.

Cell Wall

Plants have cell walls and therefore mechanical grinding in mortar pestle or liquid nitrogen is required.

Animals do not have cell walls and therefore mechanical grinding is not required.

Contaminations

The DNA extraction can be contaminated by pigments, polysaccharides or tannins.

Blood cells, platelets, plasma and proteins contaminate the animal DNA extract.

Method of Extraction

CTAB method or Edward’s method.

Phenol-chloroform method.

Visit BYJU’S for more information related to NEET.

Also see:

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1

Why is it more challenging to extract DNA from plant cells than animal cells?

It is difficult to extract DNA from plant cells as compared to animal cells because plant cells have a rigid cell wall made up of cellulose that is difficult to break down.
Q2

Is it easier to extract DNA from plants or animals?

It is easier to extract DNA from animal cells because they do not have a rigid cell wall and plant cells have secondary metabolites that often contaminate the plant DNA extract.
Q3

What are the factors affecting plant DNA extraction?

The presence of polyphenols and polysaccharides in the plant cells is the leading factor that affects DNA extraction because these molecules oxidise the DNA molecules by binding with it covalently and inhibiting enzymatic reactions.
Q4

What type of tissue is best used from plants for DNA extraction?

Young tender tissues such as leaves and buds are best to extract DNA from plant cells.

Comments

Leave a Comment

Your Mobile number and Email id will not be published.

*

*