16 August 2023 CNA
Download PDF Here
TABLE OF CONTENTS
A. GS 1 Related B. GS 2 Related C. GS 3 Related ECONOMY 1. Consumption-based poverty estimates have relevance D. GS 4 Related E. Editorials GOVERNANCE 1. Why is the Cauvery water sharing issue flaring up again? INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS 1. The Myanmar junta’s empty gestures F. Prelims Facts G. Tidbits 1. On IDay, Stalin seeks transfer of education back to State List 2. Bindeshwar Pathak, who brought in public toilet revolution, dies at 80 3. SC plans expansion of infra; eCourts to offer national link 4. With amended Act kicking in, Odisha has no ‘deemed forest’ H. UPSC Prelims Practice Questions I. UPSC Mains Practice Questions
A. GS 1 Related
Nothing here for today!!!
B. GS 2 Related
Nothing here for today!!!
C. GS 3 Related
1. Consumption-based poverty estimates have relevance
Syllabus: Indian Economy and issues relating to planning, mobilisation of resources, growth, development and employment.
Mains: Significance and methodology of consumption-based poverty estimates
Prelims: About poverty estimates
Context:
The article discusses India’s declining poverty rates based on multidimensional and consumption-based measures. It delves into challenges, critiques of multidimensional indices, and the need for reliable data for accurate poverty assessment.
Introduction
- NITI Aayog report reveals a decline in India’s poverty rate from 25% (2015-16) to 15% (2019-21).
- UNDP-OPHI Global Multidimensional Poverty Index report indicates a drop in multidimensional poverty from 27.5% (2015-16) to 16.2% (2019-21).
- The relevance of consumption-based poverty estimates in light of multidimensional poverty analysis is to be noted.
Comparison of Poverty Estimates
- Global MPI 2018 report commends India’s significant reduction in multidimensional poverty over a decade.
- The Tendulkar Committee methodology shows a decrease of 137 million in poor population between 2004-05 and 2011-12.
- Rangarajan Committee methodology highlights a decline of 92 million poor individuals per annum between 2009-10 and 2011-12.
- Tendulkar and Rangarajan methodologies exhibit lower poverty ratios compared to global MPI estimates.
Challenges with Multidimensional Poverty Measures
- Non-income dimensions of poverty may not be directly linked to consumption-based poverty lines.
- Multiple indicators pose problems of measurability, aggregation, and data availability.
- Aggregation challenges arise from the non-commensurability of indicators, such as child mortality and safe drinking water.
- Analytically appropriate aggregation rules require data to relate to the same household, which presents data constraints.
Experts’ Views on Multidimensional Indices
- Srinivasan suggests including public services as a dimension of poverty but is critical of multidimensional indices.
- Deaton and Drèze emphasise supplementing expenditure-based poverty estimates with indicators related to nutrition, health, education, and environment.
Relevance of Income and Consumption-based Poverty Measures
- Income and consumption define poverty, with various non-income indicators reflecting inadequate income.
- Official data on consumer expenditure post-2011-12 is unavailable; comparison with the multidimensional poverty index is challenging.
- There are different conclusions from studies using indirect methods and data from CMIE and PLFS sources.
Importance of Consumption Expenditure Surveys and Data Changes
- Current consumption expenditure survey is essential for accurate comparison.
- Poverty reduction is strongly associated with high growth periods; the reduction rate may have slowed in recent years.
- Differences in aggregate consumption estimates between NSS and NAS data sources; widening gap over time.
- The National Statistical Office is urged to study discrepancies and suggest data collection improvements.
- Need to analyse the impact of public expenditure on health and education across different expenditure classes.
Nut Graf: Amidst India’s reduced poverty rates, a NITI Aayog report highlights a decline from 25% (2015-16) to 15% (2019-21), while a UNDP-OPHI report notes a shift from 27.5% to 16.2%. This analysis explores the intricacies of these metrics, challenges with multidimensional poverty measures, and views on indices, and emphasises the significance of consumption-based measures and reliable data collection.
D. GS 4 Related
Nothing here for today!!!
E. Editorials
1. Why is the Cauvery water sharing issue flaring up again?
Syllabus: GS-2, Government policies and interventions for development in various sectors and issues arising out of their design and implementation.
Mains: Current issues associated with Cauvery water-sharing dispute
Background
- The Tamil Nadu government has asked the Supreme Court to order Karnataka to discharge 24,000 cubic feet per second (cusecs) from its reservoirs immediately.
- Additionally, it sought the Court to order Karnataka to see that the 36.76 TMC mandated in the final decision of the Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal (CWDT) is released.
Cauvery Water Sharing
- Karnataka, the upper riparian State in the Cauvery basin, has a monthly plan in place for releasing water to Tamil Nadu.Â
- The Cauvery Water Management Authority (CWMA) and Cauvery Water Regulation Committee (CWRC) were constituted four months after the SC issued its ruling in 2018 regarding the CWDT’s 2007 award to ensure the execution of the ruling.Â
- The two organisations have been meeting ever since to assess the issue.
Study in detail: Cauvery Water Dispute
Current Issue
- According to the water sharing plan, Karnataka must make a total of 177.25 TMC accessible to Tamil Nadu at Biligundlu during a “normal” water year (June to May).Â
- From this total, 123.14 TMC is to be distributed between June and September, which also happens to be the southwest monsoon season.Â
- Tamil Nadu was reportedly irritated by Karnataka’s failure to adhere to the quantity decided upon at the CWRC meeting during the meeting.
Karnataka’s ResponseÂ
- Karnataka has argued that the poor inflow to its own reservoirs is a result of reduced rainfall in the Cauvery basin, notably in Kerala.
- Karnataka released water to Tamil Nadu whenever more water entered the reservoirs. Karnataka, however, was not in that situation this year.Â
- Tamil Nadu had pressed Karnataka to abide by a formula for sharing in financial hardship, but Karnataka had refused.
Way Forward
Tamil Nadu is eager to learn whether Karnataka will at least abide by the Authority’s judgement. With barely 20 TMC, the Mettur reservoir in Tamil Nadu has dangerously low storage levels and will run out of water in 10 days after accounting for dead storage and drinking water needs. The Supreme Court’s perspective on the situation is still to be determined.
Nut Graf: The Cauvery water-sharing dispute has been a cause of contention between Karnataka and Tamil Nadu since the British Raj. Tamil Nadu and especially its farmers in the Cauvery delta are eagerly awaiting word on whether Karnataka will at least abide by the Authority’s ruling.
Category: INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS
1. The Myanmar junta’s empty gestures
Syllabus: GS-2, India and its neighbourhood – relations.
Mains: Crisis in Myanmar and concerns associated with Myanmar Junta Regime
BackgroundÂ
- Aung San Suu Kyi, the 78-year-old former head of state deposed in a coup in 2021, had her prison sentence recently reduced by six years.Â
- After a year in solitary confinement, the junta placed her under home arrest.Â
- Aung San Suu Kyi will nonetheless be sentenced to 27 years in prison on false charges.Â
- Additionally, the junta reduced former president Win Myint’s sentence by four years and reportedly freed more than 7,000 additional convicts.
Concerns associated with Myanmar Junta Regime
- Even a heavily staged national vote is difficult for the army’s top decision-makers to truly consider maintaining control of enough land.Â
- People have been voting with their feet in these unsettling times by emigrating abroad or enlisting in a revolutionary mobilisation.
- The majority of the country, which is the second-largest by land area in Southeast Asia, is likely off-limits to government forces.Â
- The ASEAN (Association of Southeast Asian Nations) political system is one that the regime attempts to manipulate. Â
- Significant difficulties arise for neighbours Thailand, China, India, and Bangladesh due to an unresolved civil conflict.
- Diplomatic efforts to preserve Myanmar’s territorial integrity clash with the unease about doing business with a bloody state that permeates practically everywhere.
- Violence, mistrust, terror, and martial chauvinism have taken the place of the previous political and social infrastructure.Â
- Young people in Myanmar who heroically disobeyed in the face of tanks and gunfire are no longer allowed to attend universities and are left with few options: the mountains, the jungle, or the border.
ConclusionÂ
The decision to cancel the planned elections exposes the military system’s weakness and the rulers’ paranoia. Additionally, it provides more proof that the junta cannot be trusted. The maintenance of ties with Russia and China is an important tactic. However, as long as the generals continue to use such brutality against their own citizens, there is no clear road to greater membership in ASEAN. Resistance elements seeking to gradually loosen the army’s hold on power will be further energised by the prolonging of the state of emergency and the postponement of imaginary elections. The opposition that is currently raging throughout Myanmar is unlikely to be put out by a useless decrease in the jail terms for the country’s elected leaders.Â
Nut Graf: The Myanmar army’s top decision-makers are struggling to keep control of enough territory to consider even a tightly stage-managed countrywide ballot. As a result, Myanmar is now destitute, mainly friendless, and without any kind of future strategy.
F. Prelims Facts
Nothing here for today!!!
G. Tidbits
1. On IDay, Stalin seeks transfer of education back to State List
- Tamil Nadu’s Chief Minister M.K. Stalin wants to move education control back to the State level in the Constitution’s Seventh Schedule. This shift would help stop centralised exams like NEET.
- Education used to be a State matter, but during the Emergency, the central government under Indira Gandhi moved it to a shared list with the States.
- On Independence Day, while raising the national flag at Fort St. George, Mr. Stalin remembered past Chief Ministers like C.N. Annadurai and M. Karunanidhi who wanted more autonomy for Tamil Nadu.
- Mr. Stalin believes that things that directly affect people should be under State control. He specifically mentioned that education should be given back to the State to manage.
2. Bindeshwar Pathak, who brought in public toilet revolution, dies at 80
- Who: Bindeshwar Pathak, founder of Sulabh International, a well-known social worker and recipient of the Padma Bhushan award, has died at the age of 80 due to a heart attack at AIIMS in Delhi.
- Achievements: Bindeshwar Pathak is credited with introducing the innovative Sulabh Complex public toilet system in India, which played a significant role in reducing open defecation and manual scavenging.
- Legacy: Bindeshwar Pathak was active in his non-profit work until his last days. He is survived by his wife, son, and two daughters.
- Condolences: Prime Minister Narendra Modi expressed his grief over Dr. Pathak’s death. He acknowledged Bindeshwar Pathak’s visionary efforts for societal progress and empowering marginalised communities. He praised Pathak’s contribution to the Swachh Bharat Mission.
- Accomplishments: Born and educated in Bihar, Pathak founded Sulabh International in 1970 to introduce a public toilet system across India, positively impacting many towns. He was awarded the Padma Bhushan in 1991 and became an ambassador for the Swachh Bharat Mission.
- Welfare Initiatives: Sulabh International not only advanced sanitation but also helped those involved in manual scavenging transition out of this occupation. The organisation received the Gandhi Peace Prize in 2016.
- Tributes: President Droupadi Murmu also expressed her condolences, acknowledging Pathak’s revolutionary contribution to cleanliness and social welfare.
3. SC plans expansion of infra; eCourts to offer national link
Introduction
- Chief Justice of India, D.Y. Chandrachud announced a project to modernise the court infrastructure for improved accessibility and inclusivity.
- The new project aims to build a new structure to house extra courts, judges’ chambers, registrar courtrooms, registrar chambers, and other necessary spaces for lawyers and litigants.
Role of Judiciary and Access to Justice
- The Chief Justice emphasised the crucial role of the judiciary in ensuring that government institutions operate within constitutional boundaries.
- Courts provide a safe space for individuals to seek the protection of their rights and liberties.
- The Supreme Court has played a key role in promoting access to justice and upholding constitutional values.
Technology and Modernization
- Technology is a powerful tool to enhance court efficiency, transparency, and accessibility.
- Phase 3 of the e-Courts project aims to revolutionise the court system by connecting courts nationwide, establishing paperless processes, digitising records, and creating advanced e-sewa kendras in court complexes.
- The Supreme Court uses technology to make its premises and services friendly for people with disabilities.
- Measures like screen-readable websites and case files are implemented to aid the blind community in accessing court services.
4. With amended Act kicking in, Odisha has no ‘deemed forest’
- The government of Odisha has informed district officials that requests to use forest land for non-forestry purposes should now align with the revised Forest Act. The concept of “deemed forests” will no longer exist.
- “Deemed forest” refers to land not officially designated as forest by the Central or State governments.Â
- A 1996 Supreme Court decision required states to identify and protect such land if it meets the dictionary definition of a forest.
- Approximately half of Odisha’s forest land falls under the category of “deemed forest.” However, the Odisha government’s interpretation of the Forest Act could potentially lead to an increase in deforestation.
- This interpretation may contrast with assurances given by the Environment Ministry to a parliamentary committee that “deemed forests” would continue to be safeguarded.
- Protection under the Forest Act means that land cannot be converted without the consent of both the Central government and local gram panchayats. Those changing land use must plant trees on double the cleared area and pay a significant fine.
- The 1980 Forest Act, now known as the Van (Sanrakshan Evam Samvardhan) Adhiniyam, offers protection only to officially declared forests and land specified as forest after October 25, 1980.
- In 1996, the Supreme Court expanded the Act’s scope to include areas that fit the dictionary definition of forests but were not officially labelled as such.
- States were expected to form expert committees to identify such areas; however, not all states provided these reports, leaving room for states to define or exclude large land parcels from the forest definition.
- The Ministry of Environment introduced amendments to bring clarity to forest law applications, stating that changes were necessary to eliminate ambiguity.
- According to the amended Act, if forest land was legally converted for non-forest use between 1980 and 1996, the Forest Conservation Act would not apply. This implies that land would lose protection unless officially designated as forest.
H. UPSC Prelims Practice Questions
Q1. Consider the following statements about a prominent social reformer and Padma Bhushan recipient:
He was known for his efforts in sanitation, and introduced the revolutionary Sulabh Complex public toilet system in India, significantly reducing open defecation and manual scavenging. He received the Padma Bhushan in 1991 and later became an ambassador for the government’s Swachh Bharat Mission. Sulabh International, under his leadership, also worked towards improving the lives of individuals involved in manual scavenging. Sulabh International was given Gandhi Peace Prize in 2016.
Identify the individual from the following options:
- Kailash Satyarthi
- Bindeshwar Pathak
- Arvind Kejriwal
- Kiran Bedi
CHECK ANSWERS:-
Answer: b
Explanation:Â
The passage describes Bindeshwar Pathak, the founder of Sulabh International, known for his contributions to sanitation, and social work, and for receiving the Padma Bhushan award.
Q2. Which amendment transferred education from the State List to the Concurrent List in the Indian Constitution?
- 44th Amendment Act
- 42nd Amendment Act
- 73rd Amendment Act
- 86th Amendment Act
CHECK ANSWERS:-
Answer: b
Explanation:Â
The 42nd Amendment Act transferred education from the State List to the Concurrent List, allowing both the Union and States to legislate on matters related to education.
Q3. Consider the following statements:
- The Van (Sanrakshan Evam Samvardhan) Adhiniyam protects only those forests declared under the Forest Act, 1927 and land notified as forest after October 25, 1980.
- The Supreme Court’s Godavarman verdict (1996) expanded the Act’s scope to areas conforming to the ‘dictionary’ definition of forests.
- ‘Deemed forest’ refers to forest land notified by the Centre or States after 1980.
How many of the statements given above are incorrect?
- Only one
- Only two
- All three
- None
CHECK ANSWERS:-
Answer: a
Explanation:Â
Statement 3 is incorrect as ‘Deemed forest’ is forest land that has not been notified as such by the Centre or States.
Q4. With reference to Inter-State Water Disputes Tribunals in India, consider the following statements:
- These tribunals are constituted under Article 262 of the Constitution of India.
- The tribunals have exclusive jurisdiction over disputes related to the use, distribution, and control of inter-state river waters.
- The decision of these tribunals is final and cannot be challenged in any court.
How many of the statements given above are correct?
- Only one
- Only two
- All three
- None
CHECK ANSWERS:-
Answer: b
Explanation:Â
Statement 3 is incorrect; the decisions of these tribunals can be challenged in the Supreme Court (under Article 136 and in violation of Article 21).
Q5. With reference to e-Courts in India, consider the following statements:
- It aims to facilitate electronic filing of cases, online payment of fees, and virtual hearings.
- The e-Courts project is under the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology.
- The e-Courts project covers only the High Courts and the Supreme Court of India.
How many of the statements given above are correct?
- Only one
- Only two
- All three
- None
CHECK ANSWERS:-
Answer: a
Explanation:Â
Statements 2 & 3 are incorrect; the e-Courts project is under the Ministry of Law and Justice, and it covers all levels of courts.
I. UPSC Mains Practice Questions
- Myanmar holds great importance for India’s strategic interests. Do you agree? Give examples to elaborate. (15 marks, 250 words) [GS-2, International Relations]
- Despite the constitutional safeguards, interstate water disputes haven’t been resolved peacefully. Identify the reasons for these lacunae and suggest measures for their removal. (15 marks, 250 words) [GS-2, Polity & Governance]
Read the previous CNA here.
Comments