The correct option is
A 17 randomly choose between chocolate and ice cream; chocolate is typically room temperature, ice cream is cold :)
Anyway, assuming as set containing C = chocolate, and I = Ice cream, we get, as initial set,I,I,I,I,C,C,C,C. Acceptable outcomes are I,C,C,C,I,C,and C,C,I.
First round:
I,I,I,I,C,C,C,C=12
Second round:
I,I,I,C,C,C,C=47 (odds to get chocolate if first pick was ice cream)
I,I,I,I,C,C,C=37 (odds to get chocolate if first pick was chocolate)
I,I,I,I,C,C,C=47 (odds to get ice cream if first pick was chocolate)
Third round:
I,I,I,C,C,C=12 (odds to pick chocolate if previous picks yielded one of each)
I,I,I,I,C,C=23 (odds to pick ice cream if first pick and second picks were chocolate)
For {C,C,I} we haveP(E)=12×37×23=17 probability. For {C,I,C} and {I,C,C} the probability is the same12×47×12=17.