The correct option is D Students from Grade 11 preferred City A.
Option A
In grade 10,
City A = 12, City B = 7, and City C = 13.
13 is the highest number.
∴ City C has the highest preference.
Thus, option A is correct.
Option B
In grade 9,
City A = 10, City B = 9, and City C = 12.
9 is the lowest number.
∴ City B has the lowest preference.
Thus, option B is correct.
Option C
In grade 11,
City A = 11, City B = 13, and City C = 8.
13 > 11, 8
13 is the highest number.
∴ City B has the highest preference.
Thus, option C is incorrect.
Option D
In grade 12,
City A = 12, City B = 16, and City C = 12.
∴ A lesser number of students preferred City A and City C.
Thus, option D is correct.
From the given options, only option C is incorrect.