Whether an alkyl halide will undergo an
SN1 or an
SN2 reaction depends upon a number of factors. Some of the more common factors include the natures of the carbon skeleton, the solvent, the leaving group, and the nature of the nucleophile.
Only those molecules that form extremely stable cations undergo
SN1 mechanisms. Normally, only compounds that yield
3 (tertiary) carbonications (or resonancestabilized carbocations) undergo
SN1 mechanisms rather than
SN2 mechanisms. Carbocations of tertiary alkyl halides not only exhibit stability due to the inductive effect, but the original molecules exhibit steric hindrance of the rear lobe of the bonding orbital, which inhibits
SN2 mechanisms from occurring. Primary alkyl halides, which have little inductive stability of their cations and exhibit no steric hindrance of the rear lobe of the bonding orbital, generally undergo
SN2 mechanisms.
Polar protic solvents such as water favor
SN1 reactions, which produce both a cation and an anion during reaction. These solvents are capable of stabilizing the charges on the ions formed during solvation. Because
SN2 reactions occur via a concerted mechanism (a mechanism which takes place in one step, with bonds breaking and forming at the same time) and no ions form, polar protic solvents would have little effect upon them. Solvents with low dielectric constants tend not to stabilize ions and thus favor
SN2 reactions. Conversely, solvents of high dielectric constants stabilize ions, favoring
SN1 reactions.
SN2 and
E2 reactions require a good nucleophile or a strong base.
SN1 and
E1 reactions occur with strong bases with molecules whose -carbon is secondary or tertiary and in the absence of good nucleophiles.
SN1 and
E1 reactions are not synthetically useful because they almost always give a mixture of substitution and elimination products. The proportion of these products does vary with the -carbon branching, however. Generally speaking, greater branching gives more elimination products. These elimination products generally follow Saytzeff's rule. Keep in mind that the -carbon must be secondary or tertiary for
SN1 or
E1 to occur at all. Thus the branching effect is much less pronounced than in the
SN2 and
E2 reactions.
In the broader context of all substitution and elimination reactions, remember that SN1 and E1 will not occur in the presence of a strong base or a good nucleophile. In these cases, E2 and SN2 dominate their unimolecular cousins.
E1cb reactions are quite different from E1 reactions. E1 reactions require a strong leaving group and a stable cationic intermediate. The leaving group first leaves to create the cationic intermediate. Then, the elimination occurs.
E1cb is the accepted mechanism for the aldol condensation.
Key Requirements:
- There must be an acidic proton. In the case of the one depicted above, the carbonyl acidifies the alpha-carbon proton enough for it to be deprotonated.
- There usually is a bad leaving group. If it were a really good leaving group, either E1 or E2 would probably occur instead.
The key differences between the two is that
E1 goes through a cationic intermediate, while
E1cb goes through a anionic intermediate. Therefore, never propose a
E1cb in acid or a
E1 in base.Also, the
cB in
E1cb stands for conjugate base
meaning the elimination goes through the intermediate that is the conjugate base of my starting material. In this case, the enolate was the conjugate base.